Seven
That people are falsely converted to Christ has been observed
throughout the Church’s history. Every pastor, at least those who have been in
place a decade or so, are well aware of false conversions. Perhaps this is a
time when those of us who have not lived up to the high calling of service in
the church, particularly for one of the offices
in the Church (see Ephesians 4:11-13), to examine our conversion. Paul spoke of
a spiritual self examination in 2 Corinthians 13:5:
Examine yourselves to see whether you are in the faith; test
yourselves. Do you not realize that Christ Jesus is in you, unless, of course,
you fail the test?
This is not
to say that a false conversion must have occurred if there has been a failure,
of whatever nature. Some of whom I considered the morally finest Christians I
have ever met, turned out to be or proved to be unconverted people. Moral
uprightness is good but not proof of genuine salvation. Were not the religious
leaders of Jesus’ day at least outwardly holy? And it is likely that these priests,
synagogue leaders, scribes, and so on, were rarely if ever found out. And no
one of us has ever been completely found out; this will only happen on the Day
of Judgment at the end of the age.
Maybe I
should not write what follows, but I have discovered over the decades of my
ministry that only those who have been born from above will risk the kind of
examination Paul urges to the Corinthians. It is generally known among pastors
that only the regenerate are concerned about their salvation, since they know
that this is the only real issue in all of life. There are likely exceptions to
this rule, but most pastoral veterans will say the same.
What
can the unconverted do?
What about false conversion? I am aware that false conversions
do occur, as any pastor will observe, and most Christians also realize.
There is a bit of a paradox involved here. On one hand, we
must be called and elected, and at the same time, we must trust Jesus as our
Savior and Lord. The paradox is that, on the one hand we are called to believe
in Jesus, and yet God will save those whom He has elected or chosen. Yes, there
is the Arminian position and the Calvinistic position, and I embrace both at
once. This is the paradox—two truths alongside each other like train tracks.
There
is more that could be said here, but I want to move on to a brief examination
of at least some means that may result in false conversions. These are: decisional
conversion; doctrinal conversion, generational or cultural conversion; moralistic
conversion; conversion by imitation, and experience-based conversion.
Means
of false conversion
Decisional Conversion
It is highly likely that Charles
G. Finney, between the years 1825 and 1840, developed ways in which a person
could supposedly become a Christian. He invited seekers forward to occupy the
‘anxious seat’ and to eventually recite a prayer that was essentially a
decision to invite Christ to be one’s Savior and Lord. It proved to be a useful
tool, and it spread and spread and spread, unto the present day. Make the
decision, pray the prayer, and shazzam, you were saved. It happened to me as
well, and for nearly three decades I was a Finney man.
Later
on, I learned that this was tantamount to forcing God’s hand, at best, and even
magical thinking or practice, at worst. God, in this scenario, is not sovereign
and in control; no, the one who would or would not pray the prayer is in
charge.
Could
it be that someone, maybe aged eight or eighty, prayed the prayer, and then it
was confirmed by someone that this person was now born again? A conversion was
announced, and all on the basis of someone following instructions to pray a
prayer.
In
my experience as a Gospel preacher, to be as honest as I can, it seems to me
that sometimes the prayer resulted in a genuine salvation experience, and other
times, at some point further on, it was clear that there had not been a real
experience of salvation.
Doctrinal Conversion
Believing rightly or correctly,
answering the catechetical questions properly—does this mean that one is
certainly a Christian? I have made this error any number of times. Upon finding
a fellow traveler who had all the right statements of doctrine, surely this meant
I was in the company of a true Christian brother or sister.
While
it is fine to think biblically and be theologically solid, this does not equate
with true conversion. This error may be even more prevalent than decisional
conversion, even among fundamentalists and evangelicals.
Generational or Cultural Conversion
If I live in America, I am
Christian. I was not living in a Hindu, Buddhist, or Muslim nation, so I
counted myself a Christian. When I enlisted in the military in 1961, I checked
that I was a Protestant of the Episcopal variety. This last designation was
based on the pop, sociologically oriented book The Status Seekers,
where I learned Episcopalians were the most prestigious of the lot.
I
was obviously a Christian, because I was born and raised in the good U S of A, and
if everyone I knew did not count themselves Christian, at least the founding
fathers had been, and Christianity permeated the culture.
One
of my parents was a Christian, my grandparents had been, and I must be, too.
That did it for me.
Moralistic Conversion
It seems as though I was quite
moral up until the age of fifteen when things went south. Lust set in, the never-ending
weird thoughts going through the brain at 100 mph; I was doomed is how I
put it. Other vices set in as well. There was no hope for me, and I knew it, so
I did not try to hide behind the idea I was morally upright. Thank goodness.
There
is a twist to this, however. What I discovered, and I found this within myself,
was that after my conversion, my genuine conversion, I fell into the idea that
I was now morally upright, and I noticed more than ever before that others were
not. All the sins, except for a few, that the good Baptist pastor of mine spoke
of I had pretty much stopped, at least for fairly long stretches at a time. Of
course, I found interesting ways to justify periodic lapses.
Over
the years I have found many who pride themselves on not only their doctrinal
correctness but that they succeeded in leaving the unclean world and had
devoted themselves to Christ. In thought and action, all was well.
The
two in combination are a deadly concoction, one that lulls one to sleep before
the brain function closes down completely. The fact is, there is nothing a
person can do in terms of “work” that can affect salvation. Nothing at all;
this is the plain biblical truth.
Conversion by Imitation
During the 1970s I pastored an
evangelical church that was fairly charismatic. As the years progressed, I came
to think that if a person moved and swayed to the music, closed one’s eyes,
raised the arms to heaven, and shouted out a few hallelujahs, then salvation
must be in place. And wow, if one spoke in tongues, that sealed it. The trouble
that resulted is something I may never get over.
What
can be seen and heard can be imitated. To be part of the group, to be in, to
win acceptance, even status, only required imitating the behavior of existing
group members, which is not all that hard. I have known preachers who wowed the
crowd and even had spiritual gifts, especially that of healing, who were about
as converted as a demon. And this last sentence I do not write easily.
Experience Based Conversion
To have what is thought to be an
experience with God, which is widely promoted these days, is to assume that one
must be born again. How about “lying under the power of God” on the floor,
maybe for hours even days—does this not assure that one is a child of God?
Hmmm, I fail to think of a verse or two that supports this.
If
one is healed, does this prove one is also then born again? Again, in vain do I
look for a verse that supports such a notion. Witnessing a miracle or being
present when one is told the Holy Spirit is moving in power—these can be false
signs and wonders. It is abundantly clear that Satan performs his miracles, and
like a famous baseball broadcaster once said, “Look it up.”
Nowhere
in Scripture, and I mean nowhere, is there any idea expressed that we are to
seek after an “experience” with God. The counterfeit for a simple trusting in
Jesus Christ as Savior and Lord is experience, perhaps in an altered state of
consciousness where anything might be experienced and none of which is good.
This is no proof of anything at all. Salvation is not a feeling or an experience.
Can anyone ever be sure?
Some say yes, some say no to this
question. There is Romans 8:16: “The Spirit himself bears witness with our
spirit that we are children of God,…” The Holy Spirit convinces us, but this is
internal and individual, undocumented, and mysterious.
There are
the traditional “marks” of a Christian: conviction of sin, revelation of Jesus
as Savior and Lord, belief in the truth of the crucifixion and resurrection,
moral change, love of God, worship of God, desire to know Jesus more,
fellowship with other Christians, desire for baptism, love of receiving the
bread and the cup, faithfulness to serve, worship with tithes and offerings,
continuing desire to turn from sin, ongoing repentance, enduring the race, and getting
back up if one should fall.
When I
look at myself, I see many of the marks of a Christian. It does seem to me that
the Spirit of God indwells me and convinces me that I really am in the Family
of God. Yet these are inner convictions, subjective not objective, thus there
is room for doubt.
What to
do? Follow Jesus in faithful service and worship in any case. If I became
convinced that I was not among the elect, never mind, I would continue anyway.
And this alone proves nothing except that at minimum you recognize following
the truth of Scripture results in a more meaningful and better life than the
converse.
Some of
the Puritans would say that whether they are converted or not is something they
will leave in the hands of God. For them, they would faithfully follow Jesus as
Lord in any case. Perhaps they were guarding against pride or presumption, but
they did not rely on a sense of assurance. Assurance is blessed indeed, but
even here it is not essential.
For more
thoughts on the subject of conversion, please read my book, A Matter of Life
and Death, also previously published with the title, Are You Really Born
Again?