245 

 Soul Confusion

The March 16, 1999 television chat show, Larry King Live, featured five panelists: Robert Thurman, professor of Buddhism studies at Columbia University; Marianne Williamson, New Age author and spokesperson for the spiritist-channeled Course in Miracles; Rabbi David Aaron, expert on and proponent of Kabbalah, an occult/mystical/gnostic interpretation of Judaism; Deepak Chopra, charismatic spokesperson for a popular version of Hindu monistic thought; and Franklin Graham, head of Samaritans Purse, a Christian humanitarian organization, and son of Billy Graham, the renowned American evangelist. 

One thing they could all agree upon is the idea that human beings have souls, though there were disagreements about the origin, nature, capacity, and meaning of “soul.” Indeed, there is a great deal of confusion when it comes to what the soul actually is. This is an attempt to express the Christian or biblical view of the soul. 

What is the soul?

Though the five spokespersons differed on many points, they seemed to reach a consensus in understanding “soul.” In fact, Deepak Chopra voiced agreement with Graham’s understanding of the soul. We have long heard Billy Graham say words like: “You have a soul, and it will go to heaven or hell when you die.”

Historically, the concept of soul has been around for tens of thousands of years. The “soul” concept had its beginning in what is called “animism,” the idea that in all things lived a spirit or a soul, a spiritual entity that was core to the object. And the object could be a tree, a river, a mountain, an ant, a bear, a rock, a human being—anything at all. 

According to this idea, the human soul is a mysterious, spiritual, and immortal part of the human being that leaves the cold, dead body at death. Those on Larry King’s program who believed in some form of reincarnation were able to agree together about the soul from their own traditions, though they might have used other symbols to express the same thing. 

Confusion concerning the nature of the soul has a powerful influence among the people of Mill Valley where Miller Avenue Church is. Though the doctrine is not biblical and is absent from the teaching of the early church and several successive centuries afterward, the idea that the soul is the focus of evangelistic efforts persists in many Christian traditions. Franklin Graham was concerned about the soul. He should have been concerned about the whole person—body, mind, soul, and spirit. 

So many in our community believe in reincarnation that Graham’s doctrine on the soul would not be troublesome for them. The soul? Well, they say, it needs purifying and experiences endless lifetimes, anyway. These people do not like to think that they will be resurrected to stand before the judgment of God. “My soul” is one thing; “myself” is another. 

Total Resurrection 

The biblical doctrine is one of bodily resurrection, not the floating away of an immortal soul. We are whole, integrated beings, though the Bible writers spoke variously of mind, heart, body, flesh, spirit and soul for the sake of emphasis and illustration. A person is all of these and more, a whole being responsible to God in the totality and indivisibility of his nature. What we are in total will be raised from the dead, either to eternal life in heaven or eternal death in a much darker place. We do not have immortality in and of ourselves. This truth is found in 1 Corinthians 15:53: “For this corruptible must put on incorruption, and this mortal must put on immortality” (NKJV). 

Soul confusion must be countered by the truth of the resurrection, even if it means parting from long-established ways of thinking and preaching. Let us not give the unconverted comfort by implying that they have only some ethereal soul to be concerned about. 

A Brief History of the Soul 

Animism was a direct fore-bearer of shamanism, which probably developed twenty to thirty thousand years ago in Siberia. At first, as the scholars say, it spread both west and south and east. West into Europe, south into Africa, and east into what is now Alaska, and all the way southward down to the tip of what is now known as Argentina. This last point is clearly seen in the religions of the indigenous peoples of the Americas, which are nearly all based upon shamanism, which involves belief that shamans, with a connection to the otherworld, have the power to heal the sick, communicate with spirits, and escort souls of the dead to the afterlife. The inner dwelling of a soul, completely independent and separate from the body, became and still is a well-established spirituality. 

Probably more Christians than not hold to the idea of a soul that is 247 

somehow inside the body and survives biological death. It was a widely held belief in the Graeco-Roman world in the fourth century, which is when Christianity started to incorporate the idea into its theology, and it has remained ever since. Greek dualistic thought posits the theory that the mind, spirit, and soul are good, even divine, counterbalanced by the body, flesh and matter, which are bad, the repository of evil. Therefore, it was the soul that mattered and the soul that needed saving, while the body was simply a temporary prison for the soul. 

Flourishing in the fourth century was a revival of Greek philosophy, mainly dualism of the Neo-Platonic or Neo-Aristotelian varieties.1 

1 Dualism, among other things, viewed the body as bad, even evil, while the mind, spirit, soul, were good and connected to the divine. The body then became the prison house of the soul, which supposedly pre-existed and entered human bodies, transmigrated or left them upon death. The Eastern concepts of karma and reincarnation are dependent upon this understanding of soul.Over a millennium later the reformers such as Martin Luther and John Calvin, both ministers (priests) in the Roman Catholic Church, retained their Church’s doctrine of the soul, despite expounding salvation by grace through faith alone. Only the more radical reformers, the Anabaptists, looked for their theological foundations further back in history before Augustine of Hippo (A.D. 354–430), the great Pauline theologian, who incorporated the construct of the separate existence of the soul in the human being. The famous Augustine, one of my heroes of the Church, nevertheless was steeped in Greek philosophy and blended the dualistic concept of the soul into his Christian views. Thomas Aquinas (A.D. 1225– 1274), another great theologian, then included the Greek influenced doctrine of the soul in his Summa Theologica, minus the portion about the transmigration and pre-existence of the soul that was common to Greek philosophy. 

The Christian Protestant denominations originating out of the Reformation inherited the concept of the soul. From Luther comes the Lutheran denominations; from John Calvin and John Knox come the Reformed and Presbyterian churches, followed by the Congregational churches, the Anglican Church, and by extension both American Episcopal and Methodist churches, plus all the offshoots from these denominations. Not all the Baptists, who followed the Anabaptists, rejected the Greek influenced soul view, but many did. Pentecostals and charismatics hold a variety of concepts about the soul. 

Biblical Passages Having to Do with the Soul 

We first encounter the word “soul” in Genesis 2:7: “Then the LORD God formed the man of dust from the ground and breathed into his nostrils the breath of life, and the man became a living creature.” And the reader would be correct in protesting, where is the word “soul?” The version quoted is the English 248 

Standard Version (hereafter ESV) and has replaced “soul” with “creature.” And why? Because “creature” is a better rendering of the Hebrew nephesh than soul. The point is that God created a human being. Adam and Eve were actual people. 

The King James Version (hereafter KJV) and older English versions of the Bible translated nephesh as “soul,” and so the term stuck. Furthermore, soul has come to acquire something close to the idea of “ghost,” and not because of anything biblical. And in fact, in Job 11:20 and Jeremiah 15:9, the KJV translates the Hebrew nephesh with ghost. 

In Deuteronomy 6:5 we find the greatest of the commandments: “You shall love the LORD your God with all your heart and with all your soul and with all your might.” The Hebrew word for soul here is from nephesh. The point of the commandment, however, means that we are to love God with all of us— all of who we are—and thus the bringing together of three words that were commonly used to describe different aspects or characteristics of all that is human— heart, soul, might.2 

2 Jesus quotes Deuteronomy 6:5 and inserts the word “mind” along with heart, soul, and strength. See Mark 12:30 and Luke 10:27. Thus Jesus interprets the fulfilling of the greatest commandment to include the mind; thus love of God is conscious and thoughtful.

Many Christians, including editors of biblical texts, unreasonably retain how the KJV translated many words, due to the extreme, yet appropriate popularity of that version of the Bible; therefore, the word “soul” pops up frequently in the Old Testament. But it means creature, person, or living being, and it does not refer to something ethereal and separate from a body. It is better said that a human being is a soul. To say a human being has a soul is not a biblical construct. If you disagree, please investigate the issue and do not simply rely on tradition. 

There are literally dozens of passages in the Old Testament where it is clear that the English word soul really means person. For the purposes of this essay, two examples will be given that are characteristic of the lot. The first is from Exodus 1:5, and the KJV is, “And all the souls that came out of the loins of Jacob were seventy souls: for Joseph was in Egypt already.” Two times the word “souls” appears, and in both cases the Hebrew word is nephesh. Now the same verse in the ESV: “All the descendants of Jacob were seventy persons; Joseph was already in Egypt” (Exodus 1:5). In one instance, nephesh is translated “descendants” and in the second “persons.” The ESV gives the most natural of the translations and is more accurately reflective of the Hebrew writer’s mindset. 

The second example is from Psalm 6:3-4, and the KJV is, “My soul is also sore vexed: but thou, O LORD, how long? Return, O LORD, deliver my soul: oh 249 

save me for thy mercies’ sake.” In both cases soul is nephesh. The same verse in the ESV reads, “My soul also is greatly troubled. But you, O LORD–how long? Turn, O LORD, deliver me for the sake of your steadfast love.” Nephesh is the Hebrew word translated “soul” in “my soul” and “me” in “deliver me.” In the first instance the ESV translators have the emotional experience of the writer in mind – King David’s emotional state of mind to be exact – and so the term “soul” meets the literary requirement to better convey emotion. In the second instance “me” is more appropriate, as David is directly referring to his person. This second instance from the Psalms illustrates a wide range of translation possibilities, but “soul” speaks to us in a poetic manner. 

The Greek translation of the Hebrew Scripture known as the Septuagint, or LXX, is a translation made by Jewish scholars in Alexandria Egypt in the early part of the second century before Christ. In it, psyche is used in place of nephesh in both passages, Exodus 1:5 and Psalm 6:3-4, and this is consistently the case throughout the translation. 

Turning our attention now to the English versions of the New Testament, we see that psyche is sometimes translated “soul.” With the exception of the Gospel of Luke and the Book of Acts, the New Testament was written by Jews who inherited the Jewish understanding of the soul. Jews did not believe, in complete distinction from the Greeks, that the soul was anything other than the whole person. Old and even new translations of the New Testament tend to pull toward the KJV and translate psyche as soul. Again, we are looking at tradition. 

Let us consider some examples. One is Matthew 2:20: “Saying, Arise, and take the young child and his mother, and go into the land of Israel: for they are dead which sought the young child’s life” (KJV). “Life” is psyche, so the KJV used the proper word, thus revealing that the KJV translators knew the correct translation. The ESV also has “life” here. We will remember that psyche is the Greek equivalent for the Hebrew nephesh. 

Matthew 10:28 is a passage that convinces many that there is such a thing as a soul indwelling human beings. “And do not fear those who kill the body but cannot kill the soul. Rather fear him who can destroy both soul and body in hell.” The word “soul” appearing twice in the verse, is in both places the Greek word psyche. Here is another example of English translations yielding to the early English versions of the Bible, especially the King James Version. The usage of the word is likely a proverbial manner of speech commonly used and understood in that day, and not to be taken literally. 

Notice, Jesus does not mention the “spirit,” which is the English word used to translate the Greek “pneuma.” This point is important because we can clearly understand that Jesus is teaching that the death of a Christian, by whatever means, will not prevent that Christian from being in heaven after death. In 250 

addition, the killing of the body does not prevent a Christian from being with the Lord in heaven because of the resurrection of the body, which will be the reality for all believers in Jesus. It is not a “soul” that gives or guarantees everlasting life, but the new birth given by the power of the Holy Spirit. 

Another example is Matthew 10:39: “He that findeth his life shall lose it; and he that loseth his life for my sake shall find it” (KJV). “Life” in both places is psyche. 

Mark 3:4, and the KJV now, is helpful: “And he saith unto them, Is it lawful to do good on the sabbath days, or to do evil? to save life, or to kill?” Here “save life” uses psyche for life and is the antonym for “kill.” Obviously, Jesus has in mind a person and not a ghost, soul, or something else of an ethereal nature, which, according to some, could not be killed anyway. 

And this is the problem with importing into the Judaeo/Christian Scripture the concept of a soul that does not die or cannot be extinguished. The biblical worldview is resurrection. Jesus was resurrected; even He had no soul that survived the crucifixion. Furthermore, when Jesus cried out, “Father, into your hands I commit my spirit!” (Luke 23:46), “spirit” in the sentence is from the Greek pneuma and can be translated spirit, breath, or wind. It was essentially an idiom, a statement that would have been well understood by those who heard Him and that meant simply, “Father, as I am now dying I trust in you” – a final confession of faith. 

In the Parable of the Rich Fool Jesus describes a successful farmer who prospers greatly to the point he plows all his gain back into his business and grows increasingly wealthy. This fictional character even boasts: 

“And I will say to my soul, Soul, you have ample goods laid up for many years, relax, eat, drink, be merry. But God said to him, ‘Fool! This night your soul is required of you, and the things you have prepared, whose will they be? (Luke 12:19-20) 

“Soul” in Jesus’ parable stands for the rich fool himself. The farmer is smugly speaking about and to himself. 

Jesus uses, as He often did, the folksy and picturesque communication styles common to that era. And then we consider what it would mean that only an ethereal soul was to be extracted. What about the flesh, the mind, the heart, the spirit? 

Going now to the Book of Acts, chapter 2 and verse 41: “So those who received his word were baptized, and there were added that day about three thousand souls.” 

Peter preached the Pentecostal Day sermon in Jerusalem, the first Christian presentation of the Gospel, and 3,000 hearers were converted, and 251 

,subsequently were baptized. The “those” are referred to as “souls” at the conclusion of the verse. Not sure how souls would be baptized, but no of course, the people who were saved by the power of the Holy Spirit were baptized. This is a rather clear instance in which people are referred to as souls. 

Then a look at 1 Corinthians 15:45. First the KJV: “The first man Adam was made a living soul; the last Adam was made a quickening spirit.” Soul is psyche and spirit pneuma. The ESV translates it, “The first man Adam became a living being; the last Adam became a life-giving spirit.” Adam was a person, not something without a body. Jesus is the last Adam, the one who brought life and not death. 

The passage, Hebrews 4:12, for many seems to seal the existence of a soul apart from a body. 

For the word of God is living and active, sharper than any two-edged sword, piercing to the division of soul and of spirit, of joints and of marrow, and discerning the thoughts and intentions of the heart. 

The author of Hebrews draws upon three instances in the minds and poetry of people of that era that are so closely entwined that nothing on earth can separate them. Only God is able to do so. Indeed, the Creator God is all powerful and nothing is beyond Him. Point is here that the phrase “of soul and of spirit” does not give credence to the existence of a separate entity called the soul, which most people living in the Graeco-Roman world would have believed in. It was a fitting point of reference for the biblical writer. 

The words of the Apostle Peter in 1 Peter 1:9 “. . . obtaining the outcome of your faith, the salvation of your souls” are often cited by those who support the concept of a non-material soul. Peter writing to those who had never had the opportunity to see Jesus in the flesh, said that they still had “the salvation of your souls.” 

We are more than a soul; we are people who are to receive salvation. Our bodies will be changed in an instant and we will be in the presence of God and not just an ethereal soul. 

Another one of the passages often used to support the concept of a soul that is separate and distinct from a person is Revelation 6:9, and this having to do with the opening of the fifth seal: “When he opened the fifth seal, I saw under the altar the souls of those who have been slain for the word of God and for the witness they had borne.” 

We note that “souls” comes from psyche first of all. These souls are “under the altar.” One might question here: Are souls visible or invisible? The author of Revelation, John the Apostle, could see the souls. Now going on to verses 10 and 11 we see something very interesting.252 

They [the souls] cried out with a loud voice, “O Sovereign Lord, holy and true, how long before you will judge and avenge our blood on those who dwell on the earth?” Then they were each given a white robe and told to rest a little longer, until the number of their fellow servants and their brothers should be complete, who were to be killed as they themselves had been. 

The souls were given white robes. Do we easily imagine souls wearing clothes? These souls are actual Christians who had been martyred. An ethereal or non-physical entity wearing clothes? 

There is a second passage from Revelation that deserves our attention, Revelation 20:4. 

Then I saw thrones, and seated on them were those to whom the authority to judge was committed. Also I saw the souls of those who had been beheaded for the testimony of Jesus and for the word of God, and who had not worshipped the beast or its image and had not received its mark on their foreheads or their hands. They came to life and reigned with Christ for a thousand years. 

John “saw” these who had died a martyr’s death. By their appearance he knew who and what they were—not floating apparitions with ghostly features, but actual resurrected Christian people.

   

Thirty-eight

Thoughts on Retirement

“Do you think the social security system will collapse?”

“No, it will probably be there for us, but it may not

be enough.”

“Well, do you look forward to retirement then

Kent?”

“I may not be able to pastor and preach always,

but I will, God willing, never retire from serving the

Lord.”

         

I often ask myself the question, “What am I doing

here?” And thankfully, the answer becomes clearer

as the years go by. Basically I do one thing and that is

point people to Jesus, whether they are Christians or

not. In my sermons, in the Bible studies I teach, in my

conversation, and counsel, I point people to Jesus. And

I can do this all of my life; I do not have to be a pastor

to do so.

But I love the pastoral ministry precisely because

it gives me continual opportunities to say, “Look to

Jesus and be saved.” I am aware I have greater potential

for pointing to Jesus than most other members of Miller

Avenue. Therefore I am jealous of my ministry.

172

For Pastors

So then, I will never retire as long as I have breath

and strength to point others to Jesus. However, I must

plan for retirement financially. And this is often difficult

for the pastor of a small church.

I am aware that Miller Avenue must have a pastor

who can carry out the work and that will mean, sooner

than later, a younger person than myself. I can see

myself in a “pastor emeritus” status. This may not be

possible until I begin to retire and release funds for

another pastor, but I will not be able to do that unless

there is money for me to retire on and social security

may not, almost certainly will not, be enough.

What to do? At least, $2000 should be set aside each

year for an Individual Retirement Account—the IRA.

Notice I said “at least.” Pastors are eligible for a 403B

retirement plan that allows for more than $2000 to go

into a retirement account. The maximum amount is

about 16% of the total salary.

Some pastors will respond, “I would if I could.”

And I understand. At the same time, please allow me

to strongly urge the IRA yearly contribution. It amounts

to $167 a month. I know that for the small church pastor

this represents a sizeable chunk of money. If $167 is

unrealistic, then pick a number and be consistent about

it. Perhaps have whatever investment company you

go with take the money directly out of your bank

account.

It is important for a church to know their pastor

will be secure in retirement and is making the necessary

arrangements.

Young people beware; there will come a time when

even you will realize the work is more than you can

get done. Plan now for retirement, but know that you

will never really retire.

173

Thoughts on Retirement

         

  Are you putting money away for retirement?

  Have you ever talked to an investment advisor,

perhaps one in your denomination?

  If you answer no to these questions maybe it is wise

to consider your mortality and limitations.

235 

 Christian Mysticism

This chapter is taken from the book written by Kent and Katie Philpott titled, The Soul Journey: How Shamanism, Santeria, Wicca, and Charisma are Connected. It was published by Earthen Vessel Publishing in 2014. It is predominantly written from Kent’s personal point of view.

What is broadly known as Christian mysticism has existed for many centuries. The mystics’ quest was for “more” of God, to experience Him directly and personally. Within Christian mysticism is contemplative prayer, which is distinct from either vocal recitation of words, mental reflection, or mental meditation on God’s word and its meaning and application. 

Kat Kerr’s journeys into heaven to speak with the Father also fit into the classification of Christian mysticism. Within this chapter are other examples of mysticism, not all of which are or claim to be Christian in orientation: the work of Richard Foster, Mirabai Starr, Richard Rohr, and Sarah Young. 

A Connection with Christianity

Contemplative prayer shares a broad theology common to mainstream and historic Christianity. It may, however, involve certain techniques that result in a state of mind resembling or identical to an altered state of consciousness or ecstasy, which then moves it into a category similar to shamanism, Santería, Wicca, and charisma.

While a doctoral student at San Francisco Theological Seminary in San Anselmo, California, (Presbyterian), I learned about contemplative forms of Christianity. At first I was attracted to these and read somewhat extensively in the area, even attending retreats where contemplative prayer was practiced. For some reason it never worked with me; in fact, I would engage in rather heated debates with some of the “spiritual mentors” or “spiritual directors” enlisted there. In any case, I learned firsthand what was involved. 

I want to be clear that there is much in what is called contemplative prayer that I value and actually cherish. We are called to love God with all of our being, 236 

and the truth is, in our human weakness, we rarely experience a very deep love for God and what He has done for us in Christ. There are times when I long for nothing more than to simply be alone with my Bible, read favorite passages, settle back and think of Him, and pray and talk and reflect. This is normative and healthy. What I am addressing in this chapter is quite different, something that crosses the line, however faint, into an altered state of consciousness. It is that state, often called ecstasy, especially in shamanism, that exposes a person to invasion by entities that are indeed spiritual but not holy. 

Richard J. Foster 

Richard J. Foster is often associated with contemplative prayer. His book, Celebration of Discipline, published in 1978 by Harper & Row, dramatically impacted many in the years after its first appearance and is still widely used in Bible colleges and seminaries around the world. In the year following its publication, it was our primary text for a class called Spiritual Formation, which was part of my doctoral curriculum. Foster divides his twelve disciplines into three categories: Inward, Outward, and Corporate. In the first category, the Inward Disciplines are meditation, prayer, fasting, and study.1 

1 I was much taken by Foster’s work and attempted to explore it to the extent possible and to seriously engage myself in each of the twelve disciplines. I lived with the book for many months. Though I still deem much of the material in the book to fit within a broad Christian and biblical range, I consider that the very first of the Inward Disciplines, “Meditation,” crosses the aforementioned faint line. Let me explain. 

Foster indicates his awareness that Eastern forms of meditation involve the attempt to empty the mind. Then he says, “Christian meditation is an attempt to empty the mind in order to fill it.”2 

2 Richard J. Foster, Celebration of Discipline, 15. It sounds good, but is emptying the mind normative for the Christian? In my opinion, it crosses the line and has neither biblical precedent nor warrant.3 

3 By “precedent and warrant” we mean that, for a Christian to engage in such processes, it should be clearly evident that Jesus engaged in such meditation with His disciples, that such is found in the life of the primitive Church and thus recorded in the Book of Acts, and that such practice is mentioned in apostolic New Testament letters. But there is no such evidence and therefore no biblical precedent or warrant for such a practice.Christians should indeed desire the “mind of Christ” (1 Corinthians 2:16b) but that does not suggest an emptying of the mind but a transforming “by the renewal of the mind” (Romans 12:2). 

Foster also speaks of the Eastern meditative process of detachment, especially as it relates to Buddhism. He acknowledges that detachment from the 237 

confusion of the world around us is not the goal for Christians but that Christians actually go beyond that. He implies that the Christian must go through detachment to reach attachment. Again the difficulty is that many would simply say amen to this without questioning the idea of the Christian need to detach. To me, this is the perfect set up for a significant deviation from healthy and scriptural prayer and meditation. 

Even more problematic is what he says later: “It is wonderful when a particular meditation leads to ecstasy. . . .”4 

4 Ibid., 17. When I first encountered this I was much impressed, but after some attempts at what I thought was “ecstasy,” I gave up and fortunately so. The desire for ecstasy might have led me deeper into an Eastern style of meditation, to the point of going into an altered state of consciousness and thus exposing myself to invasion by unwanted and unclean spirits. 

It is precisely for this reason that the influence of Foster finally aroused my critique. What might seem harmless and even appear to conform to some of the experiences of well-known Christian mystics like John of the Cross, Teresa of Avila, and others, is in fact extremely dangerous and little different from where shamanism, Santería, and Wicca take their practitioners. 

It gets worse. Here are two sentences from Foster’s book that even more closely resemble the teachings of the religions named above: “All who acknowledge Jesus Christ as Lord are the universal priesthood of God and as such can enter the Holy of Holies and converse with the living God. It seems so difficult to bring people to believe that they can hear God’s voice.”5 

5 Ibid., 19.

On the one hand Foster expresses the biblical truth that in Christ we are seated with Him in the heavenly places, but he reaches too far in his declaration that we actually ought to hear the voice of God. Granted, there were those biblical incidents where it is reported that people heard the voice of God. These were the prophets and others, like Peter at Joppa in the run-up to the conversion of the Roman Centurion Cornelius, but it is not something found elsewhere in the Bible as a normal and regular spiritual practice. Conversations with various spirit entities are common, however, among shamans, Santerían priests and priestesses, and among witches of neo-pagan religions. This must give one pause. 

It gets even worse with Foster. Still in the chapter on meditation, he speaks of dreams. He teaches that a Christian can invite God to inform us through our dreams. “We should tell Him of our willingness to allow Him to speak to us in this way. . . . We simply ask God to surround us with the light of His protection 238 

as he ministers to our spirit.”6 

6 Ibid., 23. 

This is characteristic of Wiccan teaching, not biblical teaching. Nowhere in Scripture is there anything approaching this. It is mediumistic and spiritistic – the province of the occult. 

Foster goes on to say, “After awhile there is a deep yearning within to go into the upper regions beyond the clouds. In your imagination allow your spiritual body, shining with light, to rise out of your physical body. Go deeper and deeper into outer space until there is nothing except the warm presence of the eternal Creator. Rest in His presence. Listen quietly, anticipating the unanticipated. Note carefully any instruction given.”7 

7 Ibid., 27.Here Foster seems to promote, regardless of whether only “in the imagination,” out-of-body travel, also called astral projection, definitely belonging to the province of the shaman. 

These concepts are reminiscent of some of the errors found in charisma, in which more and more is asked, even demanded, of God. In charisma, people recently report to be conversing with angels and even Jesus. An acquaintance who is a proponent of having conversations with deity said, “You do not have to read the Scripture anymore, you can go direct.” This connects with shamanism generally, and especially with Santería and Wicca, in my view. 

Beyond Foster 

In the years from 1980 onward, I heard little of contemplative spirituality, and when I did it was from books by those who identified with the Emerging Church Movement, but not always. Though not a large emphasis among Christians, the quest for “more,” a deeper spirituality, was evident. 

Contemplative prayer is closely connected with meditation, but it is not the kind of meditation we find in the Bible, which is focused, alert, and thoughtful attention on God, who He is, and what He has done in His Son, Jesus Christ. In sharp contrast, contemplative prayer encourages an emptying of the mind in order to achieve a light, moderate, or deep altered state of consciousness. 

To do contemplative or centering prayer, one technique is to focus on a word and repeat that word over and over, much like a Buddhist mantra. The word chosen should have spiritual significance or meaning to the one praying. Perhaps one concentrates on a single lit candle or speaks a series of prayers, but the intent is to open one’s mind, soul, and heart to God. Contemplative prayer deliberately encourages the pursuit of a mystical experience with God, and the emphasis is on “experience.” 239 

Mirabai Starr: A Connection with Contemporary Mysticism 

The autumn 2012 issue of Light of Consciousness: a Journal of Spiritual Awakening contains an article by Mirabai Starr entitled, “Contemplative Life.”8 

8 Mirabai Starr is one of the best known and respected teachers and authors of meditation and contemplation today. She has a deep interest in Hinduism, Sufism, Judaism, and mystical Christian practices. Starr points out that many of the world’s religions, including Christianity, have contemplative states. Contemplation, meditation, interior prayer, mental prayer, and centering prayer are essentially synonymous terms and describe means of meeting with the “Divine Presence” that Starr writes about. 

It is in such states of consciousness that a person will encounter “otherness,” the place she considers is where the Divine Presence reveals itself. However, that “otherness” is not what she thinks it is. 

Starr then describes a process whereby, in my view, a person becomes invaded by the “divine” presences (earlier, we called them by various terms, including spirit guides, etc.) that show up in the altered state. She outlines three stages of the process: Stage one is termed purgation or via purgativa. This is where a person surrenders and leaves behind whatever god conceptions he or she has. So, the door swings open to whatever is waiting to come in. 

Stage two is via illuminativa, where that which is divine, the divine light, is poured into the now purged, clean, and waiting empty vessel. During this stage the captivation of the one praying or meditating takes place. 

In my view, this is where possession by unclean spirits occurs. 

Stage three is union, or via unitiva. This is similar to the union sought for in Yoga and is the real and actual intent or purpose of Yoga.9 

9 Yoga means union, with the All, the Universe, the One Supreme Being, and so on. Yoga, as only exercise, is Yoga in name only and is usually practiced in the West as nothing more than exercise. Here the self, or what little is left of it, joins with or merges with the One 10 

10 The “One” can be variously interpreted or understood depending on the religious concepts held by the one meditating.and actually disappears. Starr points out that this is precisely what the Christian mystics were aiming at in their contemplative practices – to be at one with God, to be in union with the Almighty. But, with what were John of the Cross and Teresa of Avila really in touch? 

What they were engaged in, and what Mirabai Starr recognizes in them and advocates, is nothing close to biblical or historic Christianity. 240 

We humans are basically repelled by holiness, and in a bizarre, even perverse way are attracted to the unholy. Prior to my conversion at age twenty-one, I shied away from Christians, because they seemed to be “holier than thou.” My friends and I embraced darker alternatives that seemed to be more fun. What Starr advocates looks and is spiritual but is not holy. For those who have not been touched by the grace of God in Christ, Starr’s pagan spirituality is oddly attractive. 

One of the chief points Starr makes is that the deep meditative state will change a person dramatically due to the profound spiritual insights thereby attained. 

I agree with her. As mentioned before, when one encounters genuine spirituality, actual and real spirit, one is transformed. That person will immediately abandon strict materialism and gravitate toward the spiritual and the mystical, almost regardless of what religion or spiritual practice is the attraction – Christianity, Hinduism, Buddhism, Sufism, Santería, Wicca, Charisma, or other. 

This meets my own experience in four decades of work as a pastor of Christian churches. Once again, it is necessary to recognize that much that is spiritual is neither good nor God. 

Satan is the master of deceit; if he is thought of as only evil and demonic, then deception is all the more probable. The demonic kingdom with which we are faced, including “the rulers, the authorities, the cosmic powers, the spiritual forces of evil in the heavenly places” (see Ephesians 6:12), will appear grand beyond description. In fact, Satan can have an appearance so attractive, he is referred to as Lucifer, the “angel of light” (see 2 Corinthians 11:14). With such power and confidence that he targeted Jesus Himself, would we not be targets? 

Richard Rohr and Falling Upward: A Spirituality for the Two Halves of Life 

For many people, the tragedies, traumas, failures, and disappointments common to the first half of life can be a catalyst for change, according to Richard Rohr. Once the idealistic views of life fall away, a person may recognize that there must be more, and this more involves the pursuit of God. His analogy is that rather than falling down when trouble descends, one may fall upward. 

In his book, Falling Upward: A Spirituality for the Two Halves of Life11

11 Falling Upward was published in 2011 by Jossey-Bass, A Wiley Imprint. I was given the book by a friend who had been given a copy of it by a pastor of a large seeker friendly church in Los Angeles. This pastor recommended the book for growth in , Father 241 

Richard Rohr, a Franciscan priest, speaks to the reality of living in a fallen world and being fallen people. It is the nature of the “path” for falling upward rather than downward that I want to address. 

Clues to the actual nature of the “path” are apparent in the blurbs on the back of the dust cover. They are as follows: Joanna Macy, author of World as Lover, World as Self, writes, “Falling Upward calls forth the promise within us and frees us to follow it into wider dimensions of our spiritual authenticity.” 

Brian McLaren, author of A New Kind of Christianity and Naked Spirituality writes, “Richard offers a simple but deeply helpful framework for seeing the whole spiritual life – one that will help both beginners on the path as they look ahead and long-term pilgrims as they look back over their journey so far.”12 

Christian maturity and spirituality. 

Jim Finley, Merton scholar and author of The Contemplative Heart, writes, “We begin to see that, as we grow older, we are being awakened to deep, simple, and mysterious things we simply could not see when we were younger.” 

Finally, from Cynthia Bourgeault, Episcopal priest and author of The Meaning of Mary Magdalene, Centering Prayer, Inner Awakening, and The Wisdom of Knowing comes, “This is Richard Rohr at his vintage best: prophetic, pastoral, practical. A book I will gratefully share with my children and grandchildren.” While each of these endorsements is vague, the implication here is mind expansion of the variety considered in this book. 

Rohr states that his favorite mystic is Lady Julian of Norwich, who lived from 1342 to 1416.13 

12 Brian McLaren is identified as an evangelical Christian and as a leader within the Emerging Church movement. After falling deathly ill, she received sixteen mystical revelations, usually entitled, “Revelations of Divine Love.” She is venerated in the Anglican and Lutheran churches but was not made a saint in the Catholic Church. In her visions she saw God as loving, not wrathful, that all people would experience His love and have salvation (she is referred to by some as a “proto-universalist”), and most importantly, that sin is necessary to enable people to begin to discover the higher way of love. It is easy to see why Richard Rohr would embrace her. 

The Christian mystics, Saints Teresa of Avila, Ignatius of Loyola, John of the Cross, and even Francis of Assisi, among many other less known Christians, focused on turning inward by means of deep prayer, meditation, and contemplation. 

Characteristic of their experiences in such mind states were visions, revelations, and words of prophecy. These were problematic, because they often contained theology that differed, and sometimes markedly so, with Scripture. 

13 From Rohr’s Introduction, xx.242 

But the revelations were accepted by some as coming from divine and therefore holy sources and not to be easily dismissed. The appeal of the ancient mystics is currently undergoing yet another renaissance. 

Rohr’s concepts are an excellent example of importing concepts from mystical, even occult-oriented, religions into spiritual practices for Christians. The popularity of this process is partially due to the fact that there are spiritual or mystical experiences connected with such practices that are entirely convincing and captivating. 

In the back of Rohr’s book is a list of related resources and recordings that are published by the Center for Action and Contemplation. The following quote is revealing: 

In January 2008, James Finley and Fr. Richard Rohr gave a conference in Albuquerque, sharing The Four Noble Truths of the Buddha, the distilled essence of Buddhist teaching. In these talks, each Truth was introduced and explored, with emphasis given to the presence of these truths at the heart of Jesus’ call to awaken to God’s presence in every detail of our lives. 

Sarah Young and Jesus Calling: Who is actually on the other end?14 

“Rest in My Presence, allowing Me to take charge of this day. Do not bolt into the day like a racehorse suddenly released. Instead, walk purposefully with Me, letting Me direct your course one step at a time.” “You are on the right path. Listen more to Me, and less to your doubts. I am leading you along the way designed just for you.” “As you focus your thoughts on Me, be aware that I am fully attentive to you.” “You must discipline yourself to live within the boundaries of today. It is in the present moment that I walk close to you, helping you carry your burdens.” “Come to Me with a teachable spirit, eager to be changed.” 

The above are but a few of the hundreds of affirming statements Sarah says Jesus spoke to her over the years. It is no wonder her books, principally Jesus Calling (published by Thomas Nelson), have become bestsellers. People who buy her books also read Joel Osteen, Joyce Meyer, and others in the health, wealth, and prosperity genre. 

Young is referred to as a woman of listening prayer. She prays then waits for Jesus to answer. She strongly affirms that He does, yet she says she does not hear an audible voice. She listens then writes or journals what Jesus places on her heart. But at the same time, she claims that what she hears in her heart are the actual words of Jesus. Inexplicably, however, she depends on the Holy Spirit 

14 Sarah Young and Jesus Calling are discussed elsewhere in this book, but her work falls more into the realm of contemplative prayer than charisma.243 

to determine if what she hears from Jesus is biblically correct! This is more than just slightly confused and confusing. 

Young wanted “more,” and she wanted it now, on this side of heaven. She knew the Bible was the word of God, but she yearned for more. The indwelling of the Holy Spirit was not enough; the Scripture alone did not satisfy; she wanted and needed more. I have noticed that when people want more they will get more, and if they want to hear from God directly they will, sooner or later, hear someone or something speaking. 

Most, if not all, of the “words of Jesus” spoken to Young are directed to her personally. She is instructed to do this and that – trust, know, believe, and so on, all expressed in the first person, “Me,” meaning Jesus. Her devotional books are purported to be a recitation of what Jesus said to her. 

It is difficult to determine if some sort of altered state of consciousness is involved in Young’s praying, but I suspect it is. I have known a number of parishioners who became so totally immersed in deep prayer they would lose track of time and place. I have experienced this myself. This was during a time when I was practicing the techniques taught by Richard Foster in his Celebration of Discipline. Being alone, quieting myself, breathing deeply, tuning out distractions, suppressing worldly concerns, sitting in a beautiful and peaceful place, perhaps with soothing music playing in the background – I could feel myself slipping into a light trance. And when I felt this happen I would become frightened to some degree and pull away. My personal experience informs me of how dangerous it is to put oneself in a spiritually exposed position, straining to listen in order to hear what God might say. 

Young’s Jesus is rather limited in what He says to her. There are continual streams of, “You are on the right path,” “Relax and trust in Me,” “I am with you,” and “Listen to Me.” These words of Jesus are rather imbalanced, however. His messages are encouraging and never otherwise; the pithy little sayings are decidedly skewed to the positive. But Jesus in Scripture is far different from this. A quick perusal in the Gospels of Matthew, Mark, Luke, and John will make it clear that Sarah’s Jesus is not the Jesus of the Bible. 

There is no actual Gospel message in what Jesus supposedly says to Sarah Young. This ought to make one suspicious. Not that what Sarah hears is unbiblical, but the whole of it is sub-Christian at best. 

At worst (and there is a worst) is that Young is listening to something or someone who is not Jesus at all but is rather imitating and counterfeiting Jesus. Helen Schuchman listened to the voice of what she thought was Jesus and came up with the Course in Miracles, a clearly mediumistic deception. Is Young following in her footsteps? My view is, yes! 

But the concerns do not stop there. Beyond Young’s descriptions of what she has experienced is her suggestion that others may also hear Jesus calling. 244 

Sarah’s books have therefore become for some a school for mediums. Naiveté on the reader’s part coupled with intent to deceive on the part of whoever or whatever is speaking to Young is an extremely dangerous combination. 

Sarah Young’s listening prayer presents a slightly different scenario from much of Christian mysticism. She does not seem to obviously seek an altered state of consciousness. However, it is in the listening mode where a light trance state may be entered, even without attempting to do so. Christian, biblically-oriented praying does not involve listening for an audible reply, whether in the open or in the mind. In that restful, contemplative state, the listening for an actual “still small voice” is the locus of concern, especially for those who have practiced going into deep meditative states of mind. The most powerful shamans can move easily into and out of their ecstasy, so that, over time, an altered state may envelope the one praying without intentionality. Again, when one is in such a state and hears a voice, the question must be asked, who is the speaker? 

Summing up 

Contemplative prayer, shamanism, Santería, Wicca, and charisma all have a common denominator, a connection that is the passive or altered state of consciousness, regardless of the means of getting there. While in such states of mind, encountering spirits seldom seems horrific and demonic. Rather, these beings seem benign, majestic, angelic, powerful, awesome, even holy, and therein is their captivating nature. These religious spiritualities bring their practitioners into the realm of beings, entities, and spirits, but they are unclean and demonic deceivers. This, I realize, is virtually impossible to accept for one captivated by spiritual forces. 

The dots are once more connected: the practices encouraged in books like Rohr’s and Young’s lead to the trance state, whether light, moderate, or deep. These states of consciousness, common to forms of Buddhism (especially Tibetan), Hinduism, Islam’s Sufism, Judaism’s Kabbalah, shamanism, Santería, Wicca (and other neo-pagan religious expressions), and charisma open the door to spiritual beings that can be enlightening and powerful but not holy.

168

Thirty-seven

Our Need for a Confessor or Mentor

“Kent, I hear you are having trouble at home. I want

you to know we are all praying for you.”

This revelation came from a member of the

congregation as I sat with my daughters and several of

their friends prior to the beginning of our Sunday

morning worship service.

“Thank you.” I replied. “Did you hear I was having

a problem?”

“Yes, that is what everyone is saying.”

The only person I spoke to was one of the associate

pastors. Yes, one daughter’s behavior was disturbing

me, and I had asked for strict confidence.

I felt greatly comforted.

         

Some years ago spiritual advisors or directors were

in vogue. This person might also function as a

“confessor,” that is, someone who could be trusted with

the deep, dark secrets and sins. Twelve Step programs

sometimes utilize such advisors, as do other programs

in seminaries and Bible colleges. Throughout much of

the history of the church there have been confessors.

169

A Councelor

The Scripture itself teaches us to confess our sins to

one another. (James 5:16) Though we do not know

much about how this operated in the early church, it

would yet be a larger part of church life and practice,

no doubt, if there were confessors who could be trusted

to keep confidence.

A discreet person who can be trusted is not easy to

find, and must be chosen, if sought for at all, with great

care.

I have trusted friends and colleagues with certain

things only to discover they were not able to hold the

confidence. People in general, I believe, have a hard

time keeping confidence. We want to be depended

upon with all our heart and soul, but we sometimes

fail. Many distressed pastors have compounded their

problems by confessing their sins and other problems

to colleagues, associates, or even members of the

church.

Of course, I know it is helpful to have another

human being to talk to, one who is empathetic and

caring, and will not give advice or make suggestions.

If an individual’s spouse can be a reliable soul mate, so

much the better. However, not all pastors are married,

and not all spouses would even want or be able to serve

as a confessor. There are things about pastoral ministry

that are not easily shared with anybody.

Perhaps it is best if our Father in heaven were our

confessor. He keeps perfect confidence and can be

relied upon to forgive and comfort us in our innermost

being.

A mentor, on the other hand, may be a valuable

asset, especially for a “young” pastor. Having someone

to learn from and be held accountable to could make

the difference between joy and despair in the pastoral

170

For Pastors

ministry. Such mentoring may be conducted on a formal

basis, but usually it is on an informal basis.

Some people I consider to be mentors have been

long dead, George Whitfield, Ashael Nettleton,

Jonathan Edwards, and Martyn Lloyd-Jones among

others. Over the years Charles Hadden Spurgeon has

proven to be my favorite. (For those who are online, at

the locator type in SEARCH.SPURGEON.) Through

their books, sermons, and other writings, they have

become people I look to in terms of experience,

theology, and the manner in which they conducted their

ministry.

Pastors will serve as confessor or mentor for others,

sometimes without realizing the exact nature of the

relationship, and perhaps it is best that they occur in

the natural and normal flow of life and ministry. I

particularly welcome the mentoring relationship

though I wonder if I am wise enough to so serve. I do

not particularly welcome the confessor relationship and

I doubt that I will allow any such arrangement on a

formal basis.

I have my mentors, some are living, some are dead,

and one is risen from the dead. I have both a confessor

and a mentor who is seated at the right hand of the

throne of God who intercedes for me. Perhaps this will

be sufficient.

         

  At this point in your life, would you prefer having a

mentor or serving as one?

  Is there anyone in your life that would fit?

223 

 Islamic Mysticism

In Ayman S. Ibrahim’s A Concise Guide to the Life of Muhammad (published by Baker Academic in 2022) is a chapter titled, “Was Muhammad a Real Historical Figure?” Here he mentions three Muhammads: The Muhammad in popular and cultural Islam, then a second, Muhammad in the Muslim traditions, and finally the Muhammad of history. We will focus only on the first of these, the Muhammad in popular and cultural Islam, otherwise known as “the legendary Muhammad.”

The Quran presents Muhammad as an ordinary man who looked to Allah for mercy and help, but not the legendary Muhammad, this popular Muhammad, who was highly venerated even to the point where he was worshipped. It is thought here that he possessed divine qualities and could influence daily lives, even perform signs and wonders, that he knew the future, could raise the dead, and heal the sick. It was believed that he could visit sick people in dreams, especially if they drank holy water or recited verses from the Quran.

In other words, Muhammad was believed to have metaphysical or mystical abilities, and so Muslims like to visit holy places, shrines, and graves, associated with him, and they do so to obtain power, blessings, and protection from evil. And such activities are condemned by mainline Muslim theologians, but still these are popular with large segments of the Muslim population around the world. These will look to Muhammad to interpret dreams, receive divine visitations, and tell their future. 

Again, this is the legendary Muhammad and not the Muhammad of the Quran. 

The reason for the inclusion of this chapter on Islamic mysticism will be plain from the following, “Summary of the Exorcist Tradition in Islam.”

Summary of The Exorcist Tradition in Islam

Kent’s personal introduction: While attending the Mill Valley Islamic Center’s Mosque in January of 2016, I noticed a book on a shelf in the foyer, and during 224 

the prayer time I skimmed through this book by Dr. Abu Ameenah Bilal Philips.1 

1 Dr. Abu Ameenah Bilal Philips, The Exorcist Tradition in Islam (Birmingham, England, UK: Al-Hidaayah Publishing & Distribution Ltd., 2007). I was stunned and had to read it. The Imam Abdullah allowed me to take it home on the promise to return it the next Friday. I bought a copy online, read every word, and began to prepare this for a section of Islamic Studies.

The Exorcist Tradition in Islam (hereafter, Exorcist Tradition) confirmed so much I already knew about “folk” Islam. Here, however, information I thought relevant to only rural Muslim folk was actually mainstream for Muslims everywhere. It also confirmed what I already knew and had written about over the years, including my first published book by Zondervan Publishing House in 1973, entitled A Manual of Demonology and the Occult. During the late 1960s and throughout the 1970s, I actively and extensively engaged in what Dr. Philips refers to as exorcism but which I call deliverance ministry, as in the Lord’s Prayer, “deliver us from evil” (see Matthew 6:13). Then, in more recent times, I wrote Deliver us from Evil: How Jesus Casts out Demons Today, published by Earthen Vessel Publishing in 2015. 

When I returned Dr. Philips book, I also gave the Imam a copy of the new book mentioned above, which he gladly received and in which he eagerly expressed interest. It seemed necessary to me then to prepare this present chapter to assist those who might deal with this subject in their outreach to Muslims. 

Notes on the introduction to The Exorcist Tradition in Islam 

Dr. Philips gives the following reason for the writing of his book: 

In the last ten years, an upsurge of interest among Muslims about possession and the spirit-world has led to the republication of most of the classical texts on this subject (p. 7). 

He also says there has been a growing number of exorcists among Muslims. This interest then is the prime reason for Dr. Philips’ book, and his work is based upon sources that are accepted by Muslim scholars as being authentic and reliable. 

Chapter One is “The Spirit World,” where the focus is on three areas: the human spirit, jinn, and angels. Chapter Two is: “Spirit Possession,” in which he discusses the reasons for possession, partial possession, magic, the Evil Eye, exorcism, the validity of the need for exorcism, the exorcist, and methods of exorcism. Chapter Three is “Modern Muslim Exorcists.” A questionnaire developed by Dr. Philips was presented to Muslim exorcists, the results of which are 225 

presented along with a profile of the 20th century Muslim exorcist and a survey of Christian exorcists. Chapter Four is the author’s opinions about exorcism. There is an appendix that consists of interviews with seventeen exorcists, followed by an index of Qur’anic verses and hadith dealing with the subject, and concluding with a bibliography. Following now is commentary on these chapters. 

Chapter One: “The Spirit World” 

In Islam there are three different categories or species of created entities: human souls, angels, and jinn, all of which are considered rational yet invisible beings. Humans have bodies that are inhabited by human spirits or souls. Both the terms ruh and nafs are used in reference to the human spirit or soul. In this section we will use the word “soul” for the human spirit. 

Souls 

Sunni Muslims believe the soul dies at death, based on Qur’an 3:185; 28:88; and 40:11. 

When a person dies, there is some disagreement among Islamic scholars about what happens to the human spirit or soul between death and the Day of Resurrection. A dominant idea is that they return to the barzakh, the place from which they originally came. It is from the barzakh that souls are “blown by angels into the human embryos” (p. 21).2 

2 Barzakh is a Persian word that means separation, that is, a spiritual state in which souls wait before being blown into humans while in the womb.

Upon death the souls of the prophets await the Day of Resurrection in the highest level of paradise, the seventh heaven. This is a lesser place than that of the martyrs, whose souls change into green birds in paradise (Abu Dawud, page 455, no. 3). In this hadith, it is also said that if the martyr leaves behind unpaid debt, he or she will not enter paradise. 

The souls of the ordinary believer will not enter the bodies of green birds in paradise; they will, however, exist in the form of birds but are not allowed to roam around in paradise, unlike those of the martyrs. 

The souls of disobedient believers are held in their graves and punished for their sins. Two kinds of disobedient believers are mentioned by Muhammad as recorded in Sahih al-Bukhari, vol. 1, p. 141, no. 215 and by Sahih Muslim, vol. 1, pp. 171–172, no. 575: “Surely, they are being punished right now, and not for major offences. One of them was not careful to protect himself from the splash of his urine, and the other used to spread rumors.” 

The souls of disbelievers sorrow greatly. These souls remain in the grave and are punished until the Day of Resurrection. Souls of believers have contact 226 

with each other just before they die, and the souls already having died inquire as to the lot and fare of acquaintances yet living. 

Some Muslim esoterics, called Batini, believe that perfect souls leave their human bodies and educate living Muslims in order to improve their souls. 

Angels 

Although angels take the form of males, as in Gabriel who appeared to Muhammad, they are considered to be neuter with no actual sexual gender. 

Names are given to some angels in Islam: Jibril or Gabriel is the angel of revelation (Qur’an 26:192–193);3 

3 Where no citation is given, the authority comes from multiple hadith.

Mikail or Michael is responsible for rain; Israfil is the angel who will blow the horn at the time of the end of the world; Malik is the name of the guardian angel of hell (Qur’an 43:77) who lights hellfire and makes sure no one escapes; Munkar and Nakir are the two angels who will determine, after a person is dead, whether he or she was a faithful Muslim; Harut and Marut were angels who were sent to the people of Babylon to determine if they had real faith or not (Qur’an 2:102); and Raqib and ‘Atid are the two angels who sit on the shoulder of each Muslim recording their good and bad deeds (Qur’an 50:17–18). The following passages in the Qur’an speak of recording angels who are not named: 82:10–11 and 50:17–18. 

Angels have authority over the heavens and the earth. Angels determine or set in motion all that happens (Qur’an 79:5 and 51:4), yet they are merely servants of Allah. Angels are able to travel at incredible speeds. 

Some angels are able to read the minds of humans, and some know the acts that were planned by people but never carried out. Angels are in constant contact with humans, from birth to death and after death. Angels are assigned to each person at the moment of conception. They inspire people to do good and guard them from doing evil (Qur’an 13:11). There are also angels who pray to Allah for people about certain matters. 

One thing angels do not do is possess humans as jinn do, nor do they incite people to do evil. 

Jinn 

Jinn are hidden from human sight. The Arabic word for jinn is janna and means that which is concealed or hidden. Jinn is the plural form and jinni is the singular form. 

The belief in jinn is shared with Jews and Christians, but most modern day Jews, as well as some Christians, disavow the existence of jinn or demons. 

Jinn originate from fire (Qur’an 15:27; 55:15) and were created before 227 

humans existed (Qur’an 15:26–27). Since jinn are created beings, they also experience death (Qur’an 28:88; 55:26; 46:18). 

Satan, or Shaytan, is close to the concept of devil or demon. There are those who say Satan was not an angel but only a jinn; however there are those who disagree and believe Iblis, which is the personal name of Satan, was among the angels, but he refused to bow down to Adam and thus became a demon or even the devil (Qur’an 7:11 and also Qur’an 26:75–78). 

Though jinn are invisible to humans, some animals can see them. Some believe that certain jinn, like the angels, can assume human shapes and forms. Some jinn take animal shapes on a constant basis. 

(Note: Here is a connection with “spirit animals” common to Shamanism and neo-pagan groups like Wicca.) 

There are three different kinds of jinn. One type flies in the air all of the time; others take the form of dogs and snakes; and others wander the earth. These latter jinn are referred to as qarin, which means companion, and they will accompany a person from their birth to their death. 

There are jinn who listen in on the conversations of angels, who inhabit a lower level of heaven, and then report their findings to fortunetellers (Qur’an 72:8–9; 15:17–18). 

Jinn can be Muslims or non-Muslims. One treats a Muslim jinn differently, almost reverently, but not so a non-Muslim jinn. Satan is a non-Muslim devil. 

Some Muslim scholars contend, and are supported by some hadith, that camels are jinn or are created from jinn. 

Some hadith say that jinn eat and drink and do so with the left hand. 

Some, mostly Sunni scholars, teach that jinn can have sexual relations with humans and may have offspring, based on Qur’an 72:6. There are hadith that report that Muhammad habitually said when entering the toilet, “O Allah, surely I seek refuge in You from evil male and female jinn.” This particular saying was collected from all six of the major hadith, i.e., Sahih al-Bukhari, vol. 1, pp. 105–106, no. 144 and Sahih Muslim, vol. p. 205, no. 729. In addition, Qur’an 55:74 and 18:50 indicate that jinn deflower females. 

Hinn are the lowest category of jinn and appear as black dogs. 

Jinn, like angels, are able to travel large distances very rapidly. They are also able to affect the human mind by implanting evil thoughts. Some jinn sleep and eat with humans without the humans being aware of it. Jinn may cause humans to be ill. 

At a person’s death, even a Muslim, jinn will attempt to cause him or her to go astray and leave the straight path of Allah. 

Jinn are the only possible source of possession of a human being; human spirits or souls or angels do not possess humans. Jinn can cause both physical and mental problems. 228 

Chapter Two: “Spirit Possession” 

Sar is the most commonly used term for possession by jinn, and only jinn can possess a human being. This word is also used to denote epilepsy and literally means, “to throw down.” Mass is also a term used to refer to spirit possession but is also used to describe mental illness or madness. A possessed person is called a mansus. An insane person is called a majnun. 

Not all Muslim scholars hold to the idea that jinn possess people; some are more likely to see marks of possession as mental or physical illness; major Islamic scholars, however, do attest to spirit possession. In fact, it is said that if one denies spirit possession of human beings it is akin to apostasy and a denial of the Qur’an. 

Qur’anic evidence for spirit possession is found in Qur’an 2:275: “Those who devour interest rise up like one stumbling from Satan’s touch.” The hadith are used to substantiate this as well, several of which have wording like, “Verily, Satan flows in the bloodstream of Adam’s descendants” (Sahih Muslim, vol. 3, pp. 1187–1188). In addition, Qur’an 14:22 suggests the possibility of spirit possession, but such is not absolutely clear from the passage itself. 

The Sunnah, the pattern of truth found in hadith, support spirit possession by jinn, and not only the possibility of such but also its reality. 

Spirit possession occurs from lack of faith in Allah, not performing prayers, lustful inclinations of jinn, or horseplay. Major trouble may occur if jinn become angry. The example given by Dr. Philips is interesting: a person accidentally splattering urine on or pouring hot water on the unseen jinn will make the jinn angry, who in retaliation may possess the offender. In general, jinn tend to be harsh, ignorant, and volatile. 

Jinn fool mediums into thinking that they, the medium, can call up spirits of the dead, who even impersonate deceased ancestors, often using unknown languages that no one can understand. 

Objects, animate or inanimate, may also be possessed, as Jinn can dwell in both. One example is that rats, which are possessed by jinn, force the necessity of putting out a candle’s flame at night less the rat use it to burn a person (see Qur’an 7:148 and 20:86–89). 

Jinn may also appear in visions, while a person is awake or asleep, in order to lead the faithful Muslim astray. 

Sihr is Arabic for magic and refers to whatever is caused by hidden forces. It can also refer to speech that is subtle and strange, and Muhammad is reported to have said, “Some forms of speech are magic” (Sahih al-Bukhari, vo. 7, p. 445, no. 662). 

In Sharia Law, magic is defined as “a contract or incantation, spoken or written, or something done which will affect the body, heart or mind of the one 229 

bewitched without actually coming in contact with him.” It is said that Allah may allow such magical deception to occur. 

Islamic scholars generally disavow the use of amulets and charms meant to ward off evil jinn, curses, and in order to achieve good fortune. There is a division amongst Muslim scholars as to the reality of magic, yet it is widely practiced, since in the Qur’an and the Sunnah magical practices are mentioned. Evidence of this is found in Qur’an 2:102; 113:4; and 7:116. Qur’an 113:4 reads, “And (I seek refuge) from the evil of the witches who blow on knots.” The blowing on knots, rope, or animal hair was a mechanism by which spells were cast. 

The Qur’anic verses 7:117 and 20:66 also refer to the reality of magical practices. Magic works through the power of jinn and Satan directly. It is evident then that spirit possession and magic are linked together, the second being dependent upon the first. 

The Evil Eye is known to all Muslims and is a major issue for them. It essentially refers to an evil glance or look, which is thought to have a powerful impact upon the person looked upon. Sahih Muslim, vol. 3, p. 1192, no. 5427 says, “The effect of the evil eye (al-‘ayn) is real, for if there were anything which could overtake destiny, it would have been (the effect of) the evil eye.” This effect is caused by jinn. 

Exorcism is the term used for the expulsion of evil spirits. The name of Allah may be invoked along with a number of other rituals such as the recitation of formulas, prayers, and the use of various artifacts, charms and amulets, thought to have spiritual power. A popular practice is for the exorcist to recite the Qur’an over a cup of water, which is then drunk by the patient. Beatings are frequently used to drive evil jinn out. 

Exorcism treatments, according to Islamic Law, are divided into prohibited and permitted categories. Prohibited and permitted treatments are those stated to be so by Islamic Law, but whatever measures prove to be of value belong to Allah. 

In Islam there is no official position known as the exorcist, but different tribes and language groups employ various titles, such as ‘amil in India and Pakistan. 

The methodology of exorcism generally involves the following steps: 

  1. The undoing of charms, where the spirit possession was the result of magic. Such charms are weakened or cancelled. Once a charm has been removed the spell is neutralized. 
  2. The possessing spirit is commanded to leave. The exorcist may engage the spirit in conversation. The jinn may be evil or good, Muslim or non-Muslim. Non-Muslim spirits may be converted to Islam. The possessing spirits can be corrected and admonished. 

230 

  1. If a jinn refuses to leave, curses may be spoken by the exorcist. Offending jinn can be scolded, threatened, and “Allah’s curse” may be used against it. 
  2. Recitations from the Qur’an may be used for physical healing as well as driving out jinn. Such authority is found in Qur’an 17:82 and 10:57. 
  3. Ayah al-Kursi means “Verse of the Footstool” (Qur’an 2:255), which the Prophet said was the greatest verse in the Qur’an as it relates to humans. This verse is said to have power when it is read over a spirit-possessed person. 
  4. Surah al-Baqarah is the second chapter in the Qur’an, also known as “The Cow.” In Sahih Muslim, vol. 2, p. 337, no. 1707, Muhammad is reported to have said, “The devil flees from a house in which Surah al-Baqarah is read.” There are 286 verses in that chapter, the longest in the Qur’an. 
  5. The Basmalah is a term that means, “In the name of Allah” or “God the Merciful, the Compassionate.” This is spoken often by Muslims and is a kind of prayer or incantation. When spoken it is said to weaken or disarm Satan and the jinn. 
  6. Ta’awwudh is a word that means taking refuge or protection from Satan in Allah (Qur’an 41:36 and 23:97–98). It is powerful to ward off evil jinn and Satan. If a person remembers Allah when entering a house and while eating, then devils will not be welcome. 
  7. Adhan and iqamah are both calls to prayer and are said to have the ability to drive away demons. 
  8. Prophetic Prayers, found in various hadith, can cure illnesses and ward off jinn. 
  9. Natural medicines such as dates may be used to ward off physical trouble caused by jinn. A bath can protect against the evil eye (Sahih Muslim, vol. 3, p. 1192, no. 5427). 
  10. Beating can be used when all else fails. It is thought that only the jinn experience the pain inflicted on the possessed person. The pain causes the jinn to depart. 

Chapter Three: “Modern Muslim Exorcist” 

Methods of Exorcism 

A number of exorcists from the following seven countries were interviewed to determine the methods they used in exorcisms. 

Egypt: Recitation of the Qur’an; Crushed lotus leaves in water and Qur’an 231 

read over it then drunk; drinking and bathing; communication with jinn; command to leave; Adhan called in right ear and Uqamah in the left ear; Qur’an read over water and olive oil, water then drunk and oil rubbed on body. 

Saudi Arabia: Qur’an recited; grasping the neck; beating; Qur’an read over olive oil and water, oil rubbed and water drunk; string tied around finger and toes followed by beating; communication with jinn; command to leave; jinn bound with an oath to leave; blowing; slapping. 

Pakistan: Scented oil poured on cotton and Qur’an read over it and given to smell; Qur’an verses recited in the patient’s ear; patient shaken; a lock of hair of the patient’s wrapped around the finger of the exorcist; beating; Amulets with Qur’anic verses tied around patient’s arm; Qur’an read over water and drunk; Nails with Qur’anic verses read over them hammered in the four corners of the patient’s house; communication with jinn; jinn scolded and commanded to leave; incantation before lighting lamps and blowing over lamps causes jinn to leave patient, enter lamp and be burned; Qur’an recited over oil and poured in patient’s ear; knot tied in patient’s hair to imprison the jinn; bound with oath to leave; Patient tied; Qur’an recited; amulet put around patient’s neck or right arm; charm burnt and smoke inhaled. 

India: Patient recites over Qur’an; Qur’an recited over water then drunk and bathed with; Qur’an recited over patient; blowing; patient tied down, talismans made of lines, numerology and knowledge of names; charms written in saffron ink on plate, washed with milk and drunk; amulets with Qur’anic verses given to patient; communication with jinn; a lock of hair grabbed to arrest the jinn; knot tied in patient’s hair; prayers; amulet worn around neck for seven days. 

Trinidad: Qur’an recited over water and drunk; Qur’an recited and blown in patient’s face; supplications; prayers; command to leave; mustard oil put in patient’s right palm and Qur’an recited over patient with blowing; mustard oil placed in patient’s ear and sealed; nostrils pinched closed and palm with mustard oil held in front of mouth; patient’s limbs massaged and pressed to determine location of jinn; communication with jinn; jinn driven upward to head and hair; tied lock of hair cut off; beating. 

Bahrain: Patient faces Mecca, and line is drawn in front of him and another drawn around him, along with supplications; Qur’anic verses are recited; light beating; communication with jinn; command to leave. 

Sudan: Exorcist touches aching body part with hand; Qur’anic verses recited; point of pain blown upon; administered only at sunrise or sunset; Qur’anic verses written on plate or bowl, then washed with water, patient drinks water and water rubbed over body; Qur’an verses or their numerical equivalent written on paper and burned while patient inhales the fumes; amulets with Qur’anic verses written on are tied to patient’s ankle, waist, or neck; beating; fasting from meat and dairy products. 232 

General notes: 

Other means of treatment are the following: the patient made unconscious by depressing the jugular veins, supposing the jinn will expose itself thereby; the jinn may be arrested by tying knots in a patient’s hair, the patient’s fingers and toes may be tied to arrest the jinn; amulets with Qur’anic verses written on them may be used; other occult sciences may also be employed. 

Most of those requesting exorcism are women. The jinn may be Muslim or non-Muslim. Exorcists attempt to convert non-Muslim jinn. In India and Pakistan there are few real cases of exorcism. Most are possessed by a single jinn. These jinn may be male or female. 

Signs of possession are the following: change of personality; physical changes; mental changes; spiritual changes. In this last category is included strong reactions to the Qur’an and/or to the adhan (the call to prayer), reaction to anything to do with the Qur’an as water drunk which the Qur’an has been recited over; abandonment of religious practices. 

Reasons for possession are the following: retaliation for harming the jinn and the patient is then possessed out of revenge; jinn love or lust in that the jinn want to have carnal love relations with the patient; mischief in which evil, non-Muslim jinn possess due to their love of sin; magic where a spell or curse is placed on the patient by other humans. 

Chapter Four: Discussion 

The author states, “Muslims today erroneously attribute the power to expel jinn to the exorcist himself, rather than the mercy of Allah, which is available to any believer” (p. 195). 

The chief and most effective element in Islamic exorcism is the use of the Qur’an. Dr. Philips writes, “Since the time of the Prophet Mohammad (peace be upon him) exorcism by Qur’anic recitation became an indisputable part of canonical prophetic tradition (the Sunnah)” (p. 196). He continues, “The practice of blowing over the demonically possessed patients or on the location where the patient complains of pain is unanimously applied by modern exorcists throughout the Muslim world at different points during their exorcising” (p. 196). 

The Qur’an is seen as a magical book, especially in regard to exorcism. This much is made plain in the description of the methods used by Muslim exorcists. An example is the reading over cups of water and/or olive oil, which apparently magically infuses the Qur’an into the liquids, then when drunk expels jinn. Dr. Philips admits that neither Muhammad nor his companions used such a means for exorcism, but such treatment did arise in the Muslim community at a later time. And this practice was based upon Qur’an 17:82 and 10:57, in addition to passages in the Sunnah. He is clear that the use of amulets and talismans 233 

is a deviation from standard Islamic practices. The use of occult sciences and numerology is an even greater deviation. As to beating, the opinion is mixed, and Dr. Philips mentions that some patients died as a result of a beating. 

The author states that the methodology of exorcism has changed little over the past fourteen centuries, and that Islam does not have persons cast in the role of exorcists (p. 205). 

Dr. Philips says, “much of the theory and practice of exorcism in Islam agrees with that of Christianity” (p. 204). It is clear that Muslim exorcists are not to employ any techniques that would involve shirk, which would be the association of any other deity with Allah. 

On this point, however, we must disagree, as we have shown in two books on the subject and after decades of active engagement with the actual and literal casting out of demons that only Jesus and those who act in his name actually cast out demons. 

Muslims and Christians both authenticate demon possession and the expelling of demons. The Muslims do so essentially in the name of Allah. Casting out demons in the name of Jesus, however, while proving demon possession, is far different from exorcism in the name of Allah. It is evident that the exorcists from the various countries, whose methodologies are presented in chapter three, rarely, if ever, commanded jinn to leave “in the name of Allah.” Other magical means were used. 

The issue of the effectiveness of Christian deliverance ministry, which employs no magical elements, is problematic for Dr. Philips, who readily admits the following: 

The question which remains to be answered regarding the Islamic view of exorcism is, “How does Islam explain successful exorcisms performed by Christians over the centuries, when it considers Christianity to be a false religion” (p. 210). 

Dr. Philips’ reasoning, and that of other Muslims who consider the issue, is that casting out of demons by Christians “in the name of Jesus” works because jinn react upon the employment of shirk, which the jinn regard as evil and so are motivated to leave the possessed person, but he also confusingly asserts that Christians cast out demons “in the name of God” and not in the name of Jesus, which would be effective. He is aware that Christian exorcism, preferably called deliverance ministry and fashioned after what is seen in the New Testament, is effectual, but only because of shirk. 

Dr. Philips asserts that those who attempt to exorcize demons in the name of Jesus or in the name of Muhammad are in the same category of error as any of the pagan religionists, which he contends is mere sorcery. And when demons do leave, or appear to leave, it reinforces the notion that there is power in such incantations. 234 

Consequently, the jinn leave the diabolically possessed during Christian and pagan exorcisms by their own free will, having accomplished their malevolent goal of misguiding mankind as promised by Satan in the Qur’an.4 

4 Quoted from page 211.

Then Qur’an 7:16–17; 15:39; and 38:82 are quoted as proof. 

A final remark 

Generally, Christians do not consider saying “in the name of Jesus” to be a magical phrase or spell or incantation. We have been part of dozens of situations where demons were cast out without the words, “in the name of Jesus” even being spoken. The phrase simply means that Jesus has defeated Satan and the demonic kingdom by means of His death, burial, resurrection, ascension, and being seated at the right hand of the Father in heaven. It is that Jesus has defeated all that belongs to Satan and the jinn. “The reason the son of God appeared was to destroy the works of the devil” (1 John 3:8). And this Muslims simply cannot accept. 

There are many points where Islam and Christianity connect, and exorcism (deliverance) is one of them. Perhaps it is one of the most significant connectors. Dr. Philips’ book makes abundantly and sadly clear that Islam has no real way of dealing with the demonic kingdom except by various incantations, prayers, and rituals, which seem not to be effective. Indeed, the average Muslim is at the mercy of a most vicious foe. Combating magic with magic is deceptive, ineffectual, and dangerous. 

It is in the realm of spiritual warfare where Bible-based Christians will be able to connect with Muslims and share the love of God with them. Certainly, Jesus Christ is the only One who casts out demons, and this is one ministry Christians will be able to bring to Muslim friends. 

   

Thirty-six

Do Not Ask

“We have five hundred families in our church. How

about you Pastor Philpott?”

“Somewhat less than that, probably about 95% less.

And all our ‘families’ are not configured along the lines

of the traditional model. We are small and blessed.”

         

The chapter’s thesis: Do not ask other pastors about

the size of their congregations or budgets. Miller

Avenue is a small congregation. We vary in size from

30 to 60 people; there have been services when only

15 have attended. Pastors who preach conversionoriented

sermons may experience rather large

fluctuations in the numbers of people who attend the

public worship service. If someone began to preach

strong gospel sermons to a congregation that had not

heard such preaching, over time, a good percentage of

that congregation would leave. No church would ever

want to call me as a pastor when there was some

question as to whether or not most of the congregation

had actually experienced true conversion. If I were to

go to such a church, maybe as high as 50% of the

congregation would eventually leave. There would,

164

For Pastors

hopefully, be people who would become converted,

but those who realized they were not converted, and

did not want to be, would leave.

Some would become angry with me for preaching

such sermons. Some would want to hear “how to”

sermons, sermons with folksy stories and humor,

messages that would encourage, uplift, and inspire

them. Some would find a more “user-friendly” church

that would help them feel spiritual. Perhaps this

evaluation is extreme, but such a scenario could well

develop.

I was shaken, frankly, some years ago when I came

to the realization that some people at Miller Avenue

might be unconverted. I had been reading about the

great awakenings in America, particularly the First

Great Awakening, and became aware of the danger of

false conversion. I often preach conversion-oriented

sermons so that unconverted people might come to

Jesus for salvation. Though I have always considered

myself to be an evangelistic preacher, the fact is I did

not preach much of the gospel to my own congregation;

I assumed these people were genuinely born again. At

first, I thought we might lose 20 percent. We lost at

least 50 percent over the course of about a year and a

half to two years. As church attendance began to decline

people would say, “What happened to so-and-so, and

how come we are not having a lot of people come?”

These questions can be troubling, painful questions,

and there can be a tendency to take it personally. Of

course, I had an idea of the general dynamics and I

would try to relate that, but many people found it hard

to understand. The Holy Spirit will convict people of

sin and they will become uncomfortable even angry.

The fact is they can simply avoid the uncomfortable

165

Do Not Ask

feelings by going to another church or drop out

altogether.

It takes a certain amount of courage to withstand

the pressure. At one point I nearly backed down. Dear

members of the church would say, “Kent, we wish you

would preach something else for a change.” And so I

would preach something else for a change, but that

did not make much difference. Perhaps it was too late.

Other ministers heard about the shrinking Miller

Avenue. A former Miller Avenue member or two would

eventually tell the tale. In a week or two I would hear

the result. “You know minister so-and-so doesn’t agree

with you.” At the local ministerial meeting I would be

asked, “Well, Kent how is the church going? How

many people are attending now?”

I would think to myself, “Oh, I am failing. I am

not being successful; other churches are growing and

my church is getting smaller.” It is an unpleasant

feeling at minimum; however, it is something a pastor

must come to terms with. At this point I have come to

a place of acceptance, and it does not bother me as

much any more. But, at least, I learned the

inappropriateness of asking another pastor about

attendance and budget.

Pastors can get into a kind of gamesmanship—the

one who has the largest congregation and the biggest

budget is the one who is winning. Everyone wants to

know what the bottom line is. In the business world

one might hear: “How many vice presidents do you

have? What was your net last year?” “Which direction

are you sales headed in?” “What are your stock options

worth now?” These measurements are, of course,

deceiving. In addition, in my estimation, the

assumptions are false; the size of the congregation and

166

For Pastors

budget are not indicators of how well a pastor is doing.

The very reverse may actually be the truth.

We are beginning to see the outcome of the “church

growth movement”. When advanced and sophisticated

tele-marketing techniques were applied to church

growth, churches grew like crazy, staff members were

added, budgets went through the roof, property was

purchased, buildings went up, and people were filling

up the pews. Phenomenal rates of growth were

reported and everyone wanted in on it. Absolutely

staggering!

The “unchurched” were attracted to the “user

friendly,” seeker churches, attracted more to the

church, often, than to Jesus and His cross. In addition,

the unconverted do not stay very long—they are soon

off looking for the next exciting thing. And

unconverted people do not give much money and will

renege on their capital funds campaign pledge. When

it gets down to it, they are not committed servants of

Jesus. They want to be fed. They want to be cared for.

They want to be inspired and excited. They want

attention given to them. After a while that must break

down and they will go away. Now the capital funds

campaign begins to falter, the construction on the new

building is going to have to be reexamined and maybe

even terminated. Staff is going to have to be let go.

The finance committee is thrown into one desperate

meeting right after another. It is no longer any fun to

go to the church board meetings because the focus is

now on downsizing. And this is happening all across

America—sadly so.

We want to get away from thinking that bigger is

better. My view is that bigger is not always better, and

I am going to discuss this a little more in the chapters

167

Do Not Ask

“Pastoring the Small Church,” and “Pastoring the

Large Church.”

I avoid asking a pastor, “How large is the church?”

I am not going to ask another minister how large the

budget is. It is none of my business in the first place.

These have been some rather “off the cuff”

remarks. I hope I have not offended anybody unduly

by this, but I think there is something serious here—

we do not gauge our value or that of anyone else on

the basis of the size of a congregation or a budget. We are

called to be faithful servants of our Lord Jesus Christ,

and that alone matters. What I hope for more then

anything else is to hear Jesus say, “Well done, good

and faithful servant!” That must be enough for me.

         

  The best case of all: large numbers of people being

both converted and faithful in their giving. Still, is it

necessary to know the details?

  If the details are offered, or if we offer them, how

may this be done so as to honor and glorify God and

not the church and pastor?